ACCREDITATION

Verdict: Journal of Law Science is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics, editorial integrity, transparency, and fairness. The journal provides a clear and impartial procedure for handling complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions, peer review, publication practices, and publication ethics.
1. Complaints
A complaint is a formal expression of concern regarding the conduct, procedures, or practices of the journal, including matters involving editors, reviewers, editorial staff, the Publisher, or the publication process.
Complaints may be submitted by authors, reviewers, readers, researchers, Editorial Board members, editorial staff, institutions, or other relevant parties who have a legitimate concern. Complaints may concern, but are not limited to:
Complaints should be submitted in writing through email (verdict.jls@gmail.com) as the journal's official contact and should provide sufficient details and supporting evidence where applicable.
Upon receiving a complaint, the journal will:
Complaints will be handled without retaliation against the person submitting the complaint in good faith.
2. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
An appeal is a formal request by an author to reconsider an editorial decision concerning a submitted manuscript. Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they have reasonable grounds to believe that:
An appeal should be submitted by the corresponding author in writing through the journal's official email (verdict.jls@gmail.com). The appeal should clearly identify the manuscript and the decision being appealed and provide specific reasons and supporting evidence. Where appropriate, authors should respond point-by-point to the relevant editorial or reviewer comments.
The journal will assess the grounds of the appeal and may assign the manuscript to the same or different reviewers or to another editor who is independent of the original decision.
An appeal does not guarantee acceptance or publication. The purpose of an appeal is to determine whether the original decision should be reconsidered based on valid academic or procedural grounds.
3. Publication Ethics Complaints
Complaints concerning suspected research or publication misconduct will be handled in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics Policy and relevant publication ethics principles.
Such complaints may include, but are not limited to:
The journal will assess credible allegations objectively and may request explanations, evidence, or clarification from the authors or other relevant parties. Where necessary, the journal may contact the authors' affiliated institutions, research organizations, funding bodies, or other appropriate authorities to assist with an investigation. Depending on the findings, the journal may take appropriate corrective action, including issuing a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or other appropriate editorial notice.
4. Editorial Misconduct
Complaints concerning alleged misconduct by an editor or Editorial Board member will be handled independently to avoid conflicts of interest.
Editorial misconduct may include, but is not limited to:
An editor who is the subject of a complaint will not be responsible for investigating or deciding the complaint. The matter will instead be referred to another qualified editor, the Publisher, or an appropriate independent party.
5. Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest
The journal will handle complaints, appeals, and related communications confidentially to the extent possible.
6. Escalation and Final Decision
The journal will make reasonable efforts to resolve complaints and appeals fairly, objectively, and in a timely manner.
The journal will maintain appropriate records of complaints and appeals and may use the outcomes to improve its editorial policies and publication practices while protecting the confidentiality of the parties involved
Official contact for complaint/appeal
Complaints and Appeals should be sent via email: verdict.jls@gmail.com
Further sources:
COPE. 2018. Complaints and Appeals. https://publicationethics.org/news-opinion/complaints-and-appeals
COPE. Develop guidelines for promptly responding to suspected ethical breaches by authors, reviewers, and editors. https://publicationethics.org/guidance/guideline/ethics-toolkit-successful-editorial-office/develop-guidelines-responding-suspected-ethical-breaches
ACCREDITATION

ABOUT THE JOURNAL
JOURNAL PRACTICE
JOURNAL ORGANIZATION & MANAGEMENT
JOURNAL BUSINESS PRACTICES POLICY
ISSN JOURNAL
PUBLISHER ADDRESS
Verdict: Journal of Law Science
ISSN: 2985-3680
Published by CV Wahana Publikasi registered with the Directorate General of General Legal Administration with Number: AHU-0032876.AH.01.14. Year 2022.
Address: Jl. Terompong, Sumerta Kelod, Denpasar Timur, Kota Denpasar, Bali 80239, Indonesia (behind the Faculty of Postgraduate Studies, Universitas Warmadewa)
Phone: +6281362941120
Email: verdict.jls@gmail.com
Website: https://www.ojs.wahanapublikasi.com/index.php/vjlaws

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.